Hawkinson asks judge to dismiss Soden shooting case under self-defense immunity law
Motion says Soden's group chased Hawkinson down and Soden punched him inside his truck before the shots were fired
Sign up for our free newsletter and never miss a story.
Sign up freeDaniel Hawkinson's attorneys asked a McPherson County judge Saturday, Oct. 31, to declare him immune from prosecution in Joshua Soden's shooting death, arguing Kansas law justified deadly force against an attacker inside his truck.
Hawkinson, who was arrested in March, is charged with voluntary manslaughter in Soden's death.
The motion, filed in McPherson County District Court by Allen & Associates Law of McPherson, invokes K.S.A. 21-5231. The statute grants immunity from criminal prosecution and civil action to a person whose use of force was legally justified.
Once a defendant raises the claim, the state must establish probable cause that the force was not justified. The judge weighs the totality of the evidence rather than reading conflicting evidence in the state's favor, a gatekeeping role the motion says the Kansas Supreme Court has recognized.
According to the motion, Hawkinson had already left a rural McPherson County house party in his Ford F-250 when Soden, who had learned of an allegation that Hawkinson struck a woman at the party, returned to confront him. Soden set out with several others in a truck to find him and told the driver to turn around after they passed Hawkinson going the opposite direction.
The motion says the truck caught Hawkinson about two miles from the party and stopped alongside him. It says Soden forcefully opened his driver's door, grabbed him while he was seated and struck him with closed fists.
Witnesses Alister Tyler and Craigg Blankenship described the punches. Blankenship reported that others present indicated Soden was trying to pull Hawkinson from the truck.
Hawkinson told law enforcement that Soden began tugging at a loaded handgun on his waistband and that he feared Soden would get it and shoot him, so he drew the gun and fired several shots. Tyler described the shots as coming in rapid succession.
The motion also cites a Snapchat message, recovered by investigators from about six minutes before the shooting, that said, in substance, Soden's group was going to kill Hawkinson. It says Hawkinson had earlier been told people with guns were coming to the party to kill him.
The motion acknowledges two points it expects the state to emphasize: Hawkinson's truck drove over Soden's legs as he left, and Hawkinson threw the pistol out his window. The defense says he did so in a panic before later cooperating with investigators about where the gun was.
According to the motion, Hawkinson called 911 within about a minute of leaving, reported what had happened and drove to the Inman Police Department. That account is consistent with an affidavit, released in July and reported by Citizen Journal, that said Hawkinson called police after the shooting.
The McPherson County Attorney has yet to respond in court filings. Accused parties are presumed innocent until proven guilty.
This article was written using our proprietary AI system, Cronkite. The final decision to publish this article was made by a human. For more info, read our AI policy.
Found a mistake? Have a news tip or feedback to share? Contact our newsroom using the button below: